Welcome to Stuey's Smokehouse BBQ
At Stuey's Smokehouse BBQ, nestled in Locust Valley, an inviting aroma of smoked meats beckons guests into a cozy, casual setting. This delightful eatery prides itself on offering exceptional BBQ, highlighted by their tender brisket and succulent pulled pork sandwiches, both praised by satisfied patrons. The menu, though simple, delivers quality and flavor, with crowd-pleasing sides like sweet potatoes and cornbread enhancing the experience. The warm, friendly service complements the robust flavors, creating a welcoming atmosphere for all. Stuey's is not merely a restaurant; it’s a gathering place for BBQ lovers seeking comfort in every bite.
Stuey's Smokehouse BBQ: Reviews & Ratings
We stopped here mid week,mid day. The ribs were delicious and the cornbread was yummy. Tiny place with a counter. Nice people working there. Probably the best pork ribs I've had in a very long time. I shall return.
While I love food, I'm also older which means it takes a lot to impress me. Stuey's is the rare place that consistently impresses me. The brisket (i go lean bc even lean isnt too lean), sweet potato and cornbread is one of the most perfect meals on Long Island.
Delicious No frills Service is friendly/ the rest is self serve Ambiance is very casual I can't wait to go back. Order early, they sold out of the chicken. There's no dessert. Don't skip the sides.
Great find! Saw some good reviews on Yelp so my daughter and I took a ride into locust valley. Very little place with the smell of bbq wafting outside luring you in. Parking is plentiful behind the joint and it has a small, covered back area to dine in. The pulled pork was delicious, moist and just enough fat for texture and flavor. The brisket was great as well, moist and pulled apart easily. We ordered corn bread which my daughter loved s as were the sweet potatoes which were like dessert . Definitely will return
Top quality food. We walked in and the lady behind the counter was slicing apart a tender chicken. The menu is simple and it's easy to choosse what you want. Most of it was sold out by the time we arrived. My boo and I ordered a pound of the brisket with a mini cornbread and two bottles of water. It would be great if they had more non-carbonated options. We sat in the back patio and the guy behind the counter brought out our tray of yum yums along with some bbq sauce for dipping. The bbq sauce was good but it doesn't go with the brisket. It takes away the smokiness of the meat. Th brisket is so tender and tasty and the burnt ends are really good too. The cornbread is the perfect consistency and the jalapenos are tasteful but don't issue any heat. You can also see the corn inside the cornbread too! My boo and I ate everything and it was the perfect amount of food between the two of us. So glad we got to try someplace new and we'll definitely be back for more in the future! Happy eats!
Great little bbq spot. Brisket and ribs were amazing. Sides are very good and fit character of the restaurant very well. I hope the back eating area is open in winter. I like to cruise all year round and would love to stop by in winter as well.
Probably the best barbecue spot in Long Island the ribs are perfect. The brisket is perfect and oh my God the chorizo is addictive, friendly service, easy parking. All the sides are made from scratch, which seems like it should be obvious but (local place here in Seacliff where I live get their salads and sides out of a Cisco 5 gallon tub which drives me up the wall! when you spend 12 hours on cooking brisket or more and can't take -1hr to make a large thing of coleslaw or potato salad. Stueys makes everything from scratch and it shows. Always a treat to sit at the counter for good food friendly convo and smiles
Really legit bbq. Not a place to go sit down and eat at but the food amazing. Very surprising to find amazing bbq in locust valley of all places
Amazing! No need to say more! Ribs! Yum!! Don't forget the cornbread!!! I've driven past this place hundreds of times! So glad I was looking for ribs locally and found this place on Yelp!!!!
The place has room inside and a beautiful outside. Considering the weather was fabulous, we decided to stay outside. Once you come in, you are welcomed by friendly staff with a smile. The place smelled very promising! I ordered brisket, and my husband got half a rack of ribs and cole slow. My brisket was so juicy that it melted in the mouth. Every bite was so satisfactory! My husband's ribs were also delicious.
Location
-
50 Birch Hill Rd, Locust Valley, NY 11560 Hotline: (516) 277-2202
If you find yourself near Locust Valley, NY, make it a point to visit Stuey's Smokehouse BBQ. Nestled at 50 Birch Hill Rd, this charming spot offers an experience that is as much about outstanding food as it is about a welcoming atmosphere. With its casual, laid-back vibe and friendly service, Stuey's stands out as a BBQ destination for everyone, from families to casual diners.
Stuey's menu is a celebration of classic barbecue flavors. Guests rave about their smoked pulled pork and brisket, both cooked to perfection. The smoked baby back ribs steal the show, with customers like Susan G. claiming they are some of the best she’s enjoyed in years. Jason B. echoed this sentiment, praising the brisket’s perfect tenderness and the delectable sweet potatoes that accompany it.
- Lunch Special: Enjoy a hearty lunch for just $19, featuring a variety of smoked meats.
- Vegan Options: Stuey’s caters to diverse dietary needs with vegan options.
- Outdoor Experience: The covered outdoor seating adds a delightful touch, inviting guests to soak in the atmosphere while enjoying their meals.
- Accessibility: The venue is wheelchair accessible, making it welcoming for all.
Each dish at Stuey’s reflects a commitment to quality and satisfaction. The cornbread receives consistent praise for its perfect texture and subtle sweetness, adding a wonderful sidekick to the smoky flavors of the meats. Rich B. highlights the irresistible moistness of the pulled pork, with just the right amount of fat, lending depth to each bite.
One note that resonates through multiple reviews is the ambiance. It’s a tiny, no-frills space with a self-serve format that allows patrons to focus on what truly matters: the food. Trinidad R. captures this perfectly, calling it a delicious experience with friendly service. For those who appreciate BBQ without the pretentiousness, Stuey's is a perfect fit.
As you plan your visit, keep in mind that some items sell out quickly, particularly the chicken, making it wise to arrive early. The menu may be simple, but it lends itself to easy choices and highlights the quality of each dish. Ronit M.'s experience of indulging in a pound of brisket with cornbread showcases this perfectly, emphasizing the delightful balance of flavors.
Ultimately, Stuey's Smokehouse BBQ is not just a place to eat; it’s an invitation to indulge in the smoky, savory goodness of barbecue that many have come to cherish. It’s where quality meets community, and where every bite can transport you to barbecue bliss. Whether you dine in or take out, you’re in for a treat that promises to linger in your mind long after the meal is finished.
For reservations, catering, or simply to learn more, call (516) 277-2202 and prepare for a BBQ experience you won't forget!
